Revealing the Hidden Landscape of Public Metabolomics Data Reuse in MetaboLights
Revealing the Hidden Landscape of Public Metabolomics Data Reuse in MetaboLights
Karaman, I.; Payne, T.; Vizcaino, J. A.
AbstractPublic data reuse is a key driver of progress in omics sciences, including increasingly metabolomics data. In this study, we present a validated analysis of confirmed reuse of datasets from the MetaboLights data repository, one of the leading resources in the field. Candidate publications were collected via dataset identifiers (MTBLS#) using a Python-based retrieval pipeline across major publisher databases. They were next manually validated to distinguish active reuse from citation-only mentions. Overall, 272 unique publications were confirmed to have reused at least one MetaboLights dataset. Reuse is dominated by Method/Tool Development, with smaller contributions from Secondary Biological Analysis and Data Integration/Meta-analysis. LC-MS datasets account for the majority of reuse, whereas NMR and GC-MS also contribute but at a lower level. Data reuse has increased over time, with a noticeable acceleration in the most recent years. At the dataset level, reuse follows a long-tail distribution, where a small subset of datasets accounts for repeated reuse, mainly as community benchmarks. These results provide a conservative estimate of public metabolomics data reuse and show that public datasets are predominantly used for methodological and computational applications. They also indicate that reuse is under-detected when dataset identifiers are not consistently reported, highlighting the need for standardised dataset citation to improve traceability and recognition of reuse.